降低个人所得税有助于刺激国家经济
ok，我们同性恋的资料自动报废了==。从零开始，我们得再次准备。学哥给了我们些方向，走一步看一步吧。这个辩题很复杂，
你们看噢
-搞清楚经济是什么咚咚
-要如何降低？
-怎么刺激？
-刺激多久才算是刺激？
看上去很简单，但是分析起来会很混乱的。
我们当天才抽签，所以要准备双方的稿和资料。这个辩题比想象中的更复杂，讲求资料和论证，更多更多的资料和论证。
再次寻求帮助，不好意思。
p/s:论证是关键
ThatMyGoal，美静和华女，谢啦
加油=]
订阅：
博文评论 (Atom)
5 条评论:
这很不简单
我尽力而为吧
不用客气
这题好难，一时之间很难process它要的是什么。
如果以故事的方式来讲。。。
人民少交税，那么有的钱就会比较多，有钱就会花钱开支，在国内花钱开支就有可能刺激国家经济发展。不知道这个行不行？？
因为我没有辩论过。。。
a country residents' wealth increased (as you lower the tax rate)> they only have 2 choice, either spend the extra money or save/invest the extra money.
both approach will benefit the country's economy in different way.
first, the residents spending more sure the economy will do better in the country in short term but 1 point have to concern is whether the spend in local company or foreign company.
let says if a person got the extra money and he spend all the money to buy the lv bag, gucci bag. the earning will flow to the foreign economy instead of local economy.
but when those foreign company do set a factory in our country, provide jobs opportunity that will benefit local economy...if they don't hire local employer, local premises estate, residents spend money on their products and services will not or unlikely to benefit our country.
normally people get some extra income will buy the luxury which usually from foreign country. and in Malaysia, there is more company is selling daily supply item which its demand will not increase even the resident have more money...
for example, will you buy more rice to eat, or more tea tarik to drink when u got extra income? or u will spend more on buy a new computer, a new watch, or a new hand phone, when u got extra income?
maybe my example not so good...but did u get my point?
bad effect is it caused inflation...which quite bad to economy
second, actually save/invest almost same like spending...but it is benefit the economy in long-term.
other than that, save more in bank will let the bank more money supply to lend to business. and investment will increase the resident's wealth in long term way...which more money to spend in future (if the earn more than inflation rate) compare to spend today.
...................................
1 more thing to concern...lower tax rate, means government income lesser. Actually government do help in economy too... it is depend on the how the government spending the tax income... they can build more road or so called infrastructure...it provide job and local infrastructure company do earn some income... and infrastructure do help economy in different way...
like a highway...before u build a highway from kl to johor...it take a lorry to take its material from johor to kl about 10 hours... after build a highway it only take 5 hours...u will see it more cost effective to a company.
actually it is very hard question... because it is too much depend on individual's decision.
if any1 found out that one of my point is wrong or fault, feel free to discuss..haha i may wrong too...
其实楼上那位的point很不错，但是像第一个spend the extra money，很容易被反对党攻击（你是执政党吧？）。我们必须确保人民是spend在local product或invest在local company，尽可能找些权威性的数据来证明，如果没数据，最好不要将用这point，你们很难驳回对方的提问，只能说数据是最好的证明。
至于save money在银行，必须确保是国家银行或是本地银行，如果是外国银行，同样是无补于事。
Investment will increase residents' wealth。但国家经济不好时，我相信根本没有商家愿意invest，要人民把降低所得税的钱用在investment的前提是，必须确保当时的经济是良好的。
无可否认，infrastructure能刺激经济，但降低所得税会使国库少了一大笔钱，政府根本没能力再去建造更多，更好的infrastructure。
这问题还挺难的，除非你们有很好的数据，否这你们的立场很容易动摇，也很容易被反对党反驳。先想好对方大概会反问你们哪些问题，想好对策。
或许说，如果你们有很好的数据或理论，先不要太快表明出来，等对方反驳时，在理直气壮地说出来，把他们弄得哑口无言，相信这能让评审对你们另眼相看，帮你们加点分数，会让评审决得你们很厉害，像制造陷阱让对方踏入，再让自己更有机会表现。呵呵，这是心理战术。
正如你说的，你们真的需要很多有利地数据，否则会很难辨。感觉上，好像没什么帮到忙，呵呵，都是些废话。
好好加油=)
p/s:自己没什么看经济，所以最讨厌有关经济的问题，呵呵。不妨去问问有读经济的朋友，应该能帮得上忙。
p/s2:下次如果有机会去马六甲，就不用怕了，呵呵，有个免费的导游，嘻嘻。
actually the whether the bank is local bank or foreign bank, as long as the bank set up in local. because even foreign bank their purpose of set up their branch in our country is same purpose as local bank do in our country... they borrow funds from residents here(as the residents save their money in their bank, it is consider as residents borrow funds to the bank in return get interest.) and lend to somebody who need it with interest too.
main function of a bank to boost up economy is transfer the unneeded funds (resident don't spend the money today and save into bank, means they not using the funds in very short term) to the people who need the funds(like small business, personal loan, car loan and so on).
it is means bank increase the fund transfer efficiency from people who unneeded to people who needed the funds to improve economy activities(increase activities like real estate industry, car industry,).
actually the spending in local or foreign company question, i suggest u can do a survey...i think that is best support document u can get... because i don't think our country have a statistic about that issue.
u can survey about the income level, male or female, last year tax paid amount, and ask a question about "if the government lower taxes rate about 2-3%, what would you spend on with that extra money." and list some items, like hand phone, laptop, daily supplies, car(import /local), save/invest and more...
like hand phone and laptop mostly is foreign brand for sure... and check is it using all foreign employees, no local factory, or not listed in bursa malaysia...if listed means some malaysian will benefit if that foreign company earn money(as the shareholders is the boss, the income will give to shareholders.) u can check this from its financial reports which easily able to obtain from their website.
mostly a economy function of a company is provide jobs to local, selling products and provide services to local, and earn money for its shareholder. if they earn money...they more capable to do both 3 things above...
发表评论